Here To Help Clients To A Better Future

Misclassification Class Action: Unpaid Hours Alleged

by | Nov 20, 2026 | Firm News

Our clients’ misclassification class action alleges that a company operating across the nation, including in Los Angeles, labeled certain groups of its California-based employees as independent contractors, yet controlled their work like employees, and then denied them overtime, meal and rest breaks, and reimbursements for business expenses. At Makarem & Associates, we often hear from workers who assume that being called an independent contractor means they can’t be employees. In California, that label isn’t the end of the question.
What matters is how the work is actually done. And according to the complaint, the work here looked a lot like a job.
What the Misclassification Class Action Alleges: Independent Contractors on Paper
According to the complaint, the company provides outsourced services to business clients. Our clients and other workers held positions such as reviewers and editors, performing review and audit work and delivering completed reports to the company’s customers.
The complaint alleges the company classified these California employees as independent contractors. It also alleges that this classification was willful, and that the workers were really non-exempt employees paid by the hour.
Who Controlled the Work, Allegedly
The complaint describes a great deal of company control over its workers. Management allegedly assigned and adjusted work among team members and had final say over assignments and workload. The company allegedly tracked meeting attendance and could require workers to be online during set hours.
According to the complaint, the company also trained the workers, gave them its own templates and tools, told them how to do their assignments, and assigned managers to them. Those are the kinds of facts California law looks at when deciding who is really an employee.
Does Signing a Contractor Agreement Make You an Independent Contractor?
Not by itself. Under California’s ABC test in Labor Code § 2775, a worker is generally presumed to be an employee unless the hiring business establishes all three of the following:
  • The worker is free from its control and direction in doing the work.
  • The work is outside the usual course of the business.
  • The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade or business of the same kind.
Some occupations are covered by exemptions with different tests, so the answer depends on the job. The complaint alleges the company cannot meet any of the three parts.
After-Hours Messages and Missing Breaks, Our Clients Say
The complaint alleges the company required workers to respond to work communications as they arrived, and had workers answer work messages outside working hours without paying for that time. It also alleges these workers often worked more than 8 hours in a day or 40 hours in a week without overtime pay.
Because they were treated as independent contractors, as the complaint alleges, the company didn’t tell them they could take meal or rest breaks. And because they had to answer messages as they arrived, any break these workers did take was allegedly interrupted.
Pay Records and Out-of-Pocket Costs, Allegedly
According to the complaint, the company didn’t provide itemized wage statements to our clients and other workers. The complaint also alleges workers had to use their own cell phones, computers, and personal internet service for the company’s benefit without reimbursement.
Finally, the complaint alleges that workers who left the company were not paid all wages owed at separation, and that this failure was willful.
How Is a PAGA Claim Different From a Class Action?
This case includes both. The class claims seek wages and other relief on behalf of a proposed class of workers. The PAGA claim is different: it is brought on behalf of the State of California to recover civil penalties for Labor Code violations, and it is not a class action.
Before filing a PAGA claim, an employee must give written notice to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA), which has 65 days to decide whether to investigate. The complaint alleges our clients sent their notices in April and May 2026, and the LWDA did not give written notice of an intent to investigate within that window. PAGA penalties are not back wages. Under the 2024 reforms, penalties are generally split 65% to the LWDA and 35% to affected employees. You can read more at the state’s PAGA resource page.
Where the Case Stands
The case was first filed in Los Angeles County Superior Court in April 2026, and our clients filed a First Amended Class Action Complaint in August 2026. The defendants are the company and unnamed Doe defendants.
The amended complaint pleads nine claims against all defendants: Failure to Pay Minimum Wages; Failure to Pay Overtime Wages; Failure to Provide Meal Periods; Failure to Provide Rest Periods; Failure to Provide Accurate Wage Statements; Failure to Indemnify for Expenses and Losses; Failure to Pay Earned Wages Upon Termination; Unfair Competition; and Penalties Pursuant to Labor Code § 2699, et seq.
The proposed class is all non-exempt workers, however titled, employed by the company in California during the four years before the complaint was filed. The proposed class has not been certified, and whether the case proceeds as a class action is for the court to decide. Learn more about wage and hour class actions. We’ll continue to share updates as the case moves forward.
What This Case Can Teach Other California Employees
Your situation is your own, but a few points apply broadly:
  • A title isn’t a classification. Being called a contractor, consultant, or freelancer doesn’t settle whether you’re an employee under California law.
  • Look at who controls the work. Set hours, required meetings, assigned managers, and company tools can all point toward employment.
  • After-hours messages can be work. If you’re expected to answer work texts or emails off the clock, keep a simple log of when and how long.
  • Employees get breaks and pay stubs. If you’ve never been told about meal or rest breaks or never received a wage statement, ask why.
  • Track what you spend. Save records of phone, internet, and equipment costs you pay for work.
  • Claims have deadlines. They’re often shorter than people expect, so get advice early. Our Los Angeles employment law office can help you sort out the timing, and you can see some of our past verdicts and settlements.
If you’re an hourly worker in California and you’ve been treated as an independent contractor even though your employer controls how you work, you don’t have to figure it out alone. Makarem & Associates offers free consultations to help you understand your rights and your options. Reach out to us. We’re here to help.
Contact our team today!
Call us: 800-610-9646